In an October 2012 report, Human
Rights Watch estimated that some 1,500 civilians had died as a result of the
violence; by November 2013, estimates showed that this figure had risen to 5,000
deaths. In the first half of 2014, Human Rights Watch
documented the death of at least 2,053 civilians from Boko Haram attacks. The total estimates from 2009 through July 2014, revealed
that more than 7,000 civilians have died during the Boko Haram related unrest
and violence in northeast Nigeria. These figures are derived from analyzing credible local and
international media reports, the findings of human rights groups, and
interviewing witnesses and victims of numerous attacks.
Human Rights Watch has extensively
documented the widespread abuses carried out by Boko Haram as well as by the
Nigerian security forces in response to the insurgency. A 2012 report,
“Spiraling Violence: Boko
Haram Attacks and Security Force Abuses in Nigeria,” explored
the roots of the insurgency and implicated both sides in serious abuses. These include excessive use of
force, burning homes, physical abuse, and extrajudicial killings of those
suspected of supporting Boko Haram. Nigerian Security Forces have responded
to Boko Haram attacks with a heavy hand.
In July 2009, the
police and soldiers in Maiduguri carried out scores of extrajudicial killings
of detainees—many of them committed execution-style—according to
witnesses interviewed by Human Rights Watch in 2010 and 2012. One of those
executed was Boko Haram leader Mohammed Yusuf at the police headquarters in
Maiduguri.
In April
2013, security forces carried out a raid leading to massive destruction of
property and civilian death in Baga, Borno State, following a Boko Haram attack
on a military patrol in the town on April 16. Security forces have also rounded up
hundreds of men and boys suspected of supporting Boko Haram, detained them in
inhuman conditions where dehydration, hunger, illness and diseases were rampant,
and physically abused or killed them. Many others have been forcibly disappeared. Amnesty International found that following a March 14, 2014 Boko
Haram attack on Maiduguri’s Giwa Barracks, which led to the escape of
hundreds of detainees, the security forces executed hundreds of the unarmed
detainees the soldiers had recaptured. Giwa Barracks is the largest
military facility in Maiduguri.
The United Nations
International Children Emergency Fund (UNICEF) reported in a July 2014 Borno State humanitarian
needs assessment survey carried out in May 2014 that residents of Bulabulin
Ngarannam and Alajiri communities were expelled from their homes by the
security forces. Soldiers also took over the local primary school, ejecting the
internally displaced persons (IDP) who had taken refuge there. Members of the
two communities have been unable to return to their homes since the military
moved in early in 2013. The Draft Lucens Guidelines for Protecting
Schools and Universities from Military Use during Armed Conflict (Lucens
Guidelines) recognizes that military presence in schools can contribute to “students
dropping out, reduced enrollment, lower rates of transition to higher levels of
education, and overall poorer educational attainment.”
The pace and intensity of
Boko Haram’s attacks, especially against civilian targets, dramatically
increased after the
federal government imposed a state of emergency in Borno, Adamawa, and Yobe
states in mid-2013. Since then, and even
more intensely since January 2014, the group has perpetrated almost-daily
attacks on villages and towns, and laid siege to highways. In the attacks, Boko Haram has killed civilians, pillaged property, and destroyed schools,
homes, and businesses, which were often razed to the ground. The
creation in Maiduguri, around July 2013, of a civilian vigilante group known as the Civilian Joint Task Force (JTF), or
Yan Gora, also appeared to contribute to the increase in attacks against
civilians, mainly for their perceived support of the vigilante group. The activities of the Civilian JTF, which was
designed to assist national security forces, largely pushed the insurgents out
of Maiduguri and other towns and into the Sambisa Forest Reserve and the
Mandara mountain range, which runs from Gwoza in southern Borno State into
Cameroon. From this location, Boko Haram began to launch frequent attacks
against remote villages in Borno and northern parts of Adamawa.
Scores of villages in rural
Borno State, the hardest hit area, have been practically overrun. Between July and early September 2014, Boko Haram
seized and took control of more than 10 major towns in Borno, Yobe, and Adamawa
states.
The fear of abduction has forced
some civilians out of their homes. Such was the case of a 50-year-old Christian
woman, now living in Abuja, who, despite intensifying attacks near her home in
Gwoza, only fled after witnessing abductions of women and children in May 2014. An 18-year-old woman explained her motivation for
fleeing her village near Izghe. The area has been repeatedly attacked by
insurgents since February 2014, precipitating a mass displacement of residents:
My mother told me to run from our village to another town
though we know no one here, because of the scary rate of abductions of young
women, including married ones. In February my brother’s 16-year-old wife
was abducted with their two children and they have not been found ‘til
date. The insurgents returned a month later to kill my other brother and took
away his teenage wife but left her young baby behind. She managed to escape
from the insurgents’ camp, and is back home now mourning her murdered
husband. My mother became afraid that I would be the next target so she sent me
away. I have been sleeping in a church since I arrived in this town a few days
ago.
Groups Targeted by Boko Haram
Human Rights Watch research
suggests that Boko Haram has targeted Christians, students, traditional leaders,
Moslems who oppose its activities, and civil servants and their family members. Boko Haram has burned numerous churches, some with worshippers
trapped inside; killed men who refused to convert to Islam; and abducted
Christian women.
In several video
messages posted on YouTube and sent to the media, Boko Haram’s leadership
made direct threats against Christians. These include a post in January 2012,
in which the then-spokesperson issued an “ultimatum” of three days
for Christians to leave the North. In May 2014, Boko Haram’s leader
stated in another video, “This is a war
against Christians and democracy and their constitution, Allah says we should
finish them when we get them.” Former United Nations high commissioner for human
rights, Navi Pillay, publicly expressed concern over Boko Haram’s
targeting of Christians.
The insurgent group has also
targeted schools and, more recently, students. According to UNICEF, Boko Haram attacks in Borno destroyed 211
schools and in Yobe they destroyed 21. Media reports and interviews by Human
Rights Watch suggest that scores of students,
almost all boys, have been killed during attacks on schools. In a particularly
vicious attack in February 2014, Boko Haram killed up to 59 male students from
the Federal Government College, Buni Yadi, in Yobe State, while female students
were ordered to either attend Koranic schools or get married. In July 2013 a
similar attack on a government-owned boarding school in Mamudo, Yobe State,
left 43 students and teachers dead, and later that September, Boko Haram
reportedly killed more than 50 students from an agricultural college in Gujba,
Yobe State, while they slept in their dormitories.
On June 16, 2014, UNICEF
warned that attacks on schools and the abduction of schoolgirls could further
undermine access to education in parts of Nigeria, especially in the North,
which is home to nearly 6.3 million, or
60 percent, of the country’s 10.5 million out-of-school children. The federal government claimed that the abduction of
schoolgirls had hindered the country’s efforts to promote girls’
education and close the gender gap in education, which has a gross enrollment
rate for boys at 35.4 percent higher than for girls.
In March, federal government-run
secondary schools in Adamawa, Borno, and Yobe states closed and their students
were transferred to schools in other northern states, while all schools in
Borno, the worst-hit of the states under emergency rule, have been closed since
then.
Responsibility for Abductions
Human Rights Watch has
reported on abductions over the past several years, documenting the July 2009 abduction of a teenage girl found hiding
in a Maiduguri church on the first night of the July 2009 Boko Haram uprising; the abduction of a woman from her home in Maiduguri,
on July 28, 2009, after her husband was killed for refusing to renounce his
Christian faith; the 2013 abduction of several teenage girls from their homes and while selling their goods; and the
September 2013 abduction of some 20 women and girls from a checkpoint set up on
the Damaturu-Maiduguri highway. Some of the girls who had been abducted in these
attacks reportedly returned months later, a few pregnant or with infants born
during captivity.
On at least two occasions, Boko
Haram’s leader, Abubakar Shekau, has taken responsibility for the
group’s abduction of women and girls. The statements, made through video
releases to the media in January 2012 and May 2013, suggested that the
abductions were intended to retaliate against the government for its alleged
arrest and detention in 2011 and early 2012 of family members of Boko Haram
members, including the wives of Shekau and other prominent Boko Haram leaders.
In a January 2012 video, Shekau says, “Since
you are now holding our women, (laughs) just wait and see what will happen to
your own women ... to your own wives according to Sharia law.”
The May 2013 abduction of 12
women from a police barracks in Bama was the first case of abduction of more
than one woman in a single attack, and signaled the beginning of a campaign of
violence against women and girls. In a video released in May 2013, Shekau says,
“We kidnapped some women and children, including teenage girls. In a
single house in Damaturu, 8 of our women and 14 children were arrested.”
He added that “no one in the country will enjoy his women and
children” if the relatives of Boko Haram members were not released by the
security officials.
In May 2013 Nigerian military
authorities released 23 women, some of whom were identified as wives of senior
members of Boko Haram. A close contact of the group interviewed by Human
Rights Watch insists that up to 180 more female relatives of the group members
remain in custody without charge. A security analyst told Human Rights Watch that as of
April 2014, at least 46 women associated with Boko Haram were detained in
prisons in different parts of the country. A man claiming to be a member of the group, calling
in on a live radio program in July 2014, demanded that the government swap the
captive Chibok schoolgirls for its members detained by the government.
A video released by Boko
Haram in May 2014 to the media suggests other motives for the abductions of
women and girls: punishing schoolgirls for attending Western schools or
forcefully converting Christian women and girls to Islam. A 19-year-old who was
one of five secondary students in Konduga abducted while travelling home from
school explained:
There were more than 40 insurgents at the road block. As
each vehicle drove up they commanded everyone to come down and identify
themselves. When my friends and I said we were students, one of the insurgents shouted
‘Aha! These are the people we are looking for. So you are the ones with
strong-heads who insist on attending school when we have said
‘boko’ is ‘haram.’ We will kill you here today.’
The students were released
two days later after being made to renounce education and promise never to
return to school.
In a May 5, 2014 video
message in which Shekau takes responsibility for the abduction of students in
Chibok, Borno State, he described the
young women and girls as “slaves” who would be sold. He added:
“Western education is sin, it is forbidden, and women must go and
marry.” One of the
schoolgirls from Chibok who managed to escape told Human Rights Watch that, as
the girls were being driven out of the school, an insurgent asked the
schoolgirls in Hausa, “What kind of knowledge are you looking for here?
Since you are here to look for Western education, we are here to confront it
and teach you the ways of Islam”